Where are the Best Amish Restaurants in Ohio?

When you think of comfort food, what comes to mind? Is it savory beef stew and Dutch cabbage rolls? How about homemade donuts and warm apple pie? If you are searching for homemade cooking, Ohio’s Amish area is the perfect place to start. But with so many options, how do you decide where to go? Luckily, we’ve pinpointed three of the best Amish restaurants in Ohio!

Below you will find a comprehensive guide to the best Amish restaurants in Ohio, but if you are hungry for more, simply download our free Amish Country Vacation Guide! Our guide includes over 100 local recommendations on restaurants, attractions, and things to do in the area!

The Best Amish Restaurants in Ohio

The Amish Door | Wilmot, OH

The owners of the Amish Door first poured coffee and served broasted chicken for dinner in March 1977. Over 40 years later, the broasted chicken remains a local favorite! You will find all of the best traditional Amish foods here, including real mashed potatoes, homemade bread, and roast beef. After a hearty dinner, remember to stop by the The Amish Door Bakery. A piece of rhubarb crumb pie or a buttery coconut cupcake is the perfect way to end your meal.

Restaurant & Bakery Hours: Monday-Saturday

Price: $$

See the Amish Door Restaurant menus.

Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen | Mount Hope, OH

Mrs. Yoder’s Kitchen is a long time favorite of locals and tourists alike. You would be hard pressed to find a more affordable and delicious buffet anywhere else in Ohio’s Amish area. Mrs. Yoder’s has served the community with authentic Amish cuisine for over 15 years. Some of the most popular menu items include the slow roast turkey and homemade stuffing. The Amish wedding steak also comes highly-recommended!

Restaurant Hours: Monday-Saturday

Price: $$

See the Mrs. Yoder’s menus.

Boyd & Wurthmann | Berlin, OH

Boyd & Wurthmann Restaurant started in the 1930s as a grocery store. Nearly a century later, this restaurant still serves an amazing cup of coffee for only 75 cents. With so many years of experience and recipes that have passed down from generation to generation, Boyd & Wurthmann have Amish cooking down to an art. In addition to Amish Country’s best country fried steak, you will enjoy countless seasonal sweets and delicacies. Strawberry shortcake and homemade pies are among Boyd & Wurthmann’s most popular desserts!

Restaurant Hours: Monday-Saturday

Price: $

See the Boyd & Wurthmann menu.

Book Your Stay at The White Oak Inn

After a day of exploring Ohio’s Amish area, head home to our inn for a relaxing night in. In the morning, you can greet the day with a complimentary country breakfast made from local farm-fresh eggs, and produce and herbs from our own garden. Of course, no stay at the White Oak Inn is complete without experiencing our dinner. Menus are planned daily to take advantage of the finest produce, meat, and fish available in the area! 

Tucked into the woods behind the inn, our log cabins offer luxurious privacy and seclusion for your vacation. Watch the firelight flicker on the cathedral ceiling while you relax in the oversized Whirlpool tub for two, or simply look at the stars through the picture window facing out into the woods. However you choose to spend your time in Amish Country, we know that you will find peace and relaxation when you stay at The White Oak Inn!

The Amish restaurants in Ohio are just the beginning of what you’ll find in Amish Country. Remember to download your free vacation guide to find more great farms, farmers markets, and places to eat!